Sep 102011

I’m not a great fan of J. Geils Band. They have all the elements of a band I should love: Jagger-esque singer, tough guitars, all the swagger rock ‘n roll can handle, but usually their songs leave me flat. “One Last Kiss” is a giant exception…at least for me. I love this song. When I was a kid and it was a very minor hit on FM radio I used to wonder why I didn’t hear it more often, like as regularly as one of Blue Oyster Cult‘s hits. It’s the only song by them beside their super-charged cover of “I’m Lookin’ for a Love,” that holds my interest and doesn’t get bogged down in Peter Wolf‘s jive act. It sounds like any number of anthemic Graham Parker & the Rumour songs that I love. Passion is no ordinary word, but I don’t think I’ve ever run into another rock nerd who will go to the mats for “One Last Kiss.” Does anyone like this song as much as I do?

What song do you possibly like more than anyone else you know? What typically unheralded song do you suspect you like more than anyone else on the planet?


  72 Responses to “Songs Possibly Only You Like as Much as You Do”

  1. BigSteve

    For me it’s usually 80s radio hits. I didn’t get much support when I posted John Waite’s Missing You on Facebook recently. I think it’s a brilliant record, but no one I know agrees with me. I also love The System’s Don’t Disturb This Groove:

    I suspect I love that one more than anyone else on the planet.

  2. Two Winters Long by Irma Thomas.

    I’ll go through spells of listening to this song over and over. I’m sure townsfolks like Bigsteve and Hank Fan appreciate this song, but I love it so much I want to take it out behind the middle school and get it pregnant.

  3. I like One Last Kiss well enough, but not as much as you.

  4. shawnkilroy

    I could list dozens of those. Here are the first 3 that popped into my head.
    Hearts by The Gun Club
    Voyer by Kim Karnes
    My New Career by Japan

  5. ladymisskirroyale

    I’m with shawnkilroy: we could do a whole separate post on Your Mixtape of Guilty Pleasures. Mine would include:

    Rush – YYZ
    Shocking Blue – Venus
    Abba – Waterloo
    Boy George – I’ll Tumble 4 You
    Anita Ward – Ring My Bell
    Human League – Love Action
    ABC – Tears are Not Enough
    Suicidal Tendencies – Institutionalized

    But to attempt to be faithful to this post, I’ll go with a song I don’t think I’d heard in 30 years until I was reacquainted with it earlier this week. When I told Mr. Royale about it, he didn’t even recall it (until I started to play it on YouTube and he ran screaming from the room). Once hearing it, it brought me back to my teenage years, and I could distinctly see the album cover (most likely covered with seeds and rolling papers). What makes me laugh is that I heard this song again at work: one of the buildings in my school district is leased in portion to a local church group. I was walking down the hall and heard this blaring from behind the church area doors:

    The Scorpions – The Zoo

  6. tonyola

    As someone who revels in prog obscurities, there are probably hundreds of songs I like that none of my acquaintances have ever even heard. However, if we mean pop/rock guilty pleasures, I’ll throw in “Holiday” by The Other Ones. Yeah, the song is really, really dumb ’80s-synth-cheese, but the chorus hooks me every time. I can’t help it, so there. I agree that guilty pleasures would make a great topic, but we need to at least break it down some – perhaps by decade or style.

  7. cliff sovinsanity

    Perhaps I’ve misunderstood the subject of this thread. We’re not looking for guilty pleasures, but rather a seemingly innocent song that ONLY you think is brilliant. If that’s the case, I’m not sure anyone on the planet loves this song as much as I do…

    Men At Work – Overkill

    and by the way Mr Mod, what is your deal with J. Geils Band. Yes, I’m aware a roommate of yours ruined them for you. But, can’t you admit that they were talented and energetic group well beyond their bar-band blues shtick. Yes, I realize Peter Wolfe is handful, but he’s is the frontman. He’s got to move it, and if he ain’t gonna move it, you best just go on home. I appreciate a band that goes all out and puts on a great show.
    I’m pretty sure that’s a mid-west thing. A blue collar ethic of hard work and showmanship should be rewarded. Even if the band is mediocre, which I don’t think the j.Geils Band are, they can still have make a show out of it.

    • shawnkilroy

      i love Overkill more than you do. What do I need to do to prove it?

    • cliff, it’s amazing to me that you remember the story of my roommate freshman year who ruined that band for me! I do try to explain myself, and I’m glad someone’s paying attention.

      I tried to explain that I feel all the elements are there for me, but I rarely hear a song by them that I *love* for the song itself. “Must of Got Lost” is one of the better ones, for instance, but almost everything I do like by them sounds like a slightly lesser version of a song by another artist, often the Stones. Or the songs I like most sound like the 3 good songs on the Stones’ Black and Blue.

      They’re good. Peter Wolf earned his check. The other guys are good too, although that harmonica honking away incessantly does sneak up and annoy me. I never saw them live. I bet they were pretty great live.

      And yes, you did get where I was coming from on the thread. People can start their own “Guilty Pleasures” thread and go for it, but I’m usually of the belief that there’s no need to feel guilty over a song you like. I know shawnmangione would agree!

  8. How about two from both ends of range:
    Wishbone Ash “Warrior” for dual guitar fury
    Nick Kershaw “Wouldn’t It Be Good” for New Wave cheese-tasity

  9. “It’s a long way there” by “The Little River Band”. I love that song.

  10. 2000 Man

    Maybe more for a guilty pleasure thread (I don’t feel guilty, though – I’ll go to the mat for this one) but I have always loved Missing Persons – Mental Hopscotch.

    For a song I thought I might be the only person in the world that loves I’d pick Paris – Big Towne 2061, the title track from the second album by the band Bob Welch formed after he left Fleetwood Mac.

    Based on 8000 views in two years, I wasn’t far off. I have a feeling I’d be a lousy program director, but at least my radio station wouldn’t sound like any of the other ones.

  11. I am one of the few who still hold a torch for Carlene Carter — and the album Musical Shapes she did with Nick Lowe and elements of Rockpile is one of my “roots of alt-country” favorites. My favorite song on it is this duet with Dave Edmunds — Baby Ride Easy.

  12. hrrundivbakshi

    Mod, we REACH on “One Last Kiss.” I’ve always had an outsized heart full of love for that song. Even today, I could go all kinds of songwriting nerd in describing the reasons why — in other words, it’s not just “subjectively good.” It’s — yes, you’ve guessed, OBJECTIVELY EXCELLENT. This, of course, means there are RIGHT and WRONG answers to the question “Is ‘One Last Kiss’ any good?” The answer to that question is YES!

  13. hrrundivbakshi

    As for my own lonely loves, here’s the first of many:

    “Magic” by Pilot —

    Yeah, I know there aren’t many people on this list who would disagree with the notion that this is a good enough little song — but I happen to think it’s Great. In addition to all the music nerdy factors I could point out, the fact is it totally rings the inner 13 year-old bell for me. There was a time when new love *was* “magic,” and this song seems to make the case for an enthusiastic embrace of that wonderful mystery. I just love it.

  14. ladymisskirroyale

    Mr. Royale sheds a tear every time he hears “Wildfire” by Michael Murphey. That song continues to be a favorite of his, but he has to be judicial in listening to it because it can upset his day.

  15. H. Munster

    Like all right-thinking people, I recognize that the Rolling Stones are The Greatest Rock and Roll Band of All Time. But I dislike “Satisfaction,” “Paint It Black,” “You Can’t Always Get What You Want,” and “Midnight Rambler.” It’s not that I’ve heard them too much. I disliked them from the start. If I were to make my list of five best Stones songs, it would include two obscure gems, “Think” from Aftermath and “Sittin’ On A Fence” from Flowers. I never heard either of them on the radio.

  16. Richard Davies, “Chips Rafferty”

  17. misterioso

    So many possibilities here. But I’ll go with a song that is often put down in this forum as the nadir of it’s writer/performer but which I think, and always thought, is glorious: Paul McCartney’s “With a Little Luck.”

    • High five! That song is picked on unmercifully. We may have to institute anti-bullyling laws to prevent the abuse.

    • Far from the nadir — that’s everything since 1980. I will defend “Luck” as well as the entire London Town album, which is the first Wings album I ever scraped together $6.99 to buy at Target. I love Back to the Egg too. Both are loaded with good songs — and he hasn’t touched either of them since.

      • misterioso

        Good! Basically I like London Town, it is a decent record though it is a little thin on high quality songs (like With a Little Luck) and the production is pretty lackluster. The “wussy” sound works well on With a Little Luck, though, I think. As for Back to the Egg, I think it is Paul’s Street Legal: a record that gets very little love except among the cognoscenti.

      • tonyola

        I’ll tell you the problem with “Luck” – it’s a mildly-pleasant 1:50 song that’s been artlessly and thinly stretched to over five minutes. There are random and go-nowhere instrumental breaks that sound like backing tracks as well as overly-cutesy “with a little luck with a little luck” choruses. It’s like Paul ran out of any real ideas once he got the basic verse/chorus structure down.

  18. God help me, but I really love “MMM-Bop” by Hanson….Hey, where’d everybody go?

    • Bobby, I have a very discrete high-five coming your way, but I will deny it if anyone notices.

      • I remember one of those VH1 “I Love the ’90s” nostalgia shows where they bring in third rate comics amongst others to poke fun at people and events. Naturally, the lame comics had a field day with Hanson. However, Scott Ian of Anthrax said that he refused to put down Hanson because they were kids who wrote their own songs, played their own instruments, and sang the songs themselves. For that, he said, they deserved respect. That’s class, Scott.

        • misterioso

          Yeah, to a point I agree with Mr. Anthrax. But if the song sucks the fact that they wrote it themselves, play it themselves, and sing it themselves doesn’t get them too far in my book. But as far as that goes, I thought and still think the song is no worse than a lot of disposable pop of other eras, so I never quite understood all the grief they got.

    • BigSteve

      Yeah that’s a good one.

  19. I really love “Jackie Blue” by the Ozark Mountain Daredevils. Everything else I’ve heard by them is third-rate southern rock, so “Jackie Blue” just came out of nowhere. Effeminate, slightly creepy, but beautiful lead vocal and melody. And the use of the slide guitar is more psychedelic than southern. Came out about the same time as “Magic” by Pilot, and both songs have stayed with me all this time.

  20. How Do You Do by Mouth & McNeal

twitter facebook youtube