Dec 092010
 

Greetings, fellow townspeeps!  Readers familiar with our ongoing Mach Schau series will know what the drill is here. Essentially, we’re looking to you to help explain why the performances we post are as compelling as we think they are. And by we, I mean me, of course. This time around, though… there’s a twist!

Following are three clips–all featuring the same song, “Treat Her Right”–a big hit in the early ’60s. The first two versions you’ll see are performed by the man who originally made the song a hit, Roy Head. Head was a white Southeast Texas soul man who got his start–very unusually for that time and region–playing in black clubs and juke joints. He was so convincingly “black” on record, in fact, that he would routinely shock audiences when the curtain rose. Then he’d get to moving and grooving, and, well, the following two clips will explain why the color of his skin no longer mattered.

Treat Her Right by Roy Head #1

Treat Her Right by Roy Head #2

Anyhow, the third clip is of the same song, this time as performed by perennial Schau-Stopper and RTH fave Tom Jones. You’ll see a different interpretation on display, but one which I venture to say is no less compelling.

Treat Her Right by Tom Jones

In any case, the drill remains the same: Discuss. Explain. Elaborate. Pick a favorite if you must.

SHOWDOWN (choose one): Which version of "Treat Her Right" is the Mach Schau-est of all?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

I look forward to your responses.

HVB

Share
Dec 082010
 

A few questions on this December 8, 2010…

What’s the most Lennonesque song by another artist since John Lennon‘s death, 30 years ago today?

Which artist, if any, since that time, has best embodied the Lennon spirit of lifetime achievement?

Did Paul McCartney‘s unfortunate reaction to John’s death solidify the lifetime of backlash Paul has since suffered?

Was “Watching the Wheels” John’s effort at initiating Kokomotion?

Had John not died, which newer generation artist would have collaborated with him first in the 1980s? Which newer generation artist would have most regrettably collaborated with him in the last 10 years?

Share
Dec 082010
 

Townspeople,

This is your Rock Town Hall!

If you’ve already got Back Office privileges and can initiate threads, by all means use your privileges! If you’d like to acquire such privileges, let us know. If you’ve got a comment that needs to be made, what are you waiting for? If you’re just dropping in and find yourself feeling the need to scat, don’t hesitate to register and post your thoughts. The world of intelligent rock discussion benefits from your participation. If nothing else, your own Mr. Moderator gets a day off from himself. It’s a good thing for you as well as me! Continue reading »

Share
Dec 072010
 
A couple of recent threads (here and here) brought to mind the phenomenon of bands with at least two band members sharing a surname but no lineage (ie, “no relation,” as it always says after the band members’ names are listed). Because I’m sure there are so few of these instances, I won’t use up one of the options by kicking off this Last Man Standing with an initial entry, but I will say that the members of The Ramones do not count. Also, because I’ve felt so often, in the past, that a Last Man Standing will result in no more than three or four possible answers, I will refuse to believe I’m about to “stump” anyone this time. Go!
Share
Dec 072010
 

As you may know, there’s no period of The Rolling Stones that I like better than what I call the “Brian Jones era.” I refer to it as such with full knowledge that Jones may not have contributed much, after helping Mick Jagger and Keith Richards to come together and study Da Blooz, beyond his ability to drive the band with his awesome Rhythm Look and an aptitude for coloring songs with his vast collection of “exotic” instruments. What’s never been clear to me, though, is whether Jones actually contributed anything special on the guitar. I, as much as Richard Lloyd, Martin Belmont, and anyone else who’s passed through these hallowed halls, frequently refer to the band’s legendary twin-guitar attack, but can we actually pinpoint what Jones did other than stay out of the way of Richards’ riffs?

A couple of weeks ago E. Pluribus Gergely called me with the following discovery, which he said was the first example he’s seen of Jones playing an audible, prominent rhythm guitar part. It’s the band playing “Oh Carol” on the Mike Douglas Show in 1964. I’ve watched this clip a few times and, although Jones’ part is easily discernable, I think my friend gave Jones a little too much credit. The execution is nothing special, is it?

I’d love to hold onto the belief that Richards-Jones set the template for all that I love about twin-guitar attacks in rock ‘n roll, but please help me find live video evidence of Jones doing anything worthwhile on guitar. Thanks.

By the way, Douglas and his old fart guests’ dismissive intro of the band and the segment at the end of the lip-synched performance of “Tell Me,” when a couple of giddy teenagers come up to meet the band, are priceless.

Finally, it goes without saying that I’m not allowing the following lip-synched performance as evidence, as much as I’d love to:

Continue reading »

Share

Lost Password?

 
twitter facebook youtube